Tag: Crown lands

Part 2 of the "Nothing to do with Land" series. This article exposes how self-government frameworks in Newfoundland are quietly constructed long before public consultation begins. Through funding streams labeled “capacity building” and “governance readiness,” Ottawa lays the legal and administrative groundwork without ever invoking the word “land.” Using federal programs, REDBs, and cultural grants, it shows how culture is transformed into jurisdiction behind closed doors. Drawing on academic sources and recent examples from western Newfoundland, the piece argues that what locals believe is “just heritage” is often the first phase of a full governance framework under Section 35. In the end, it reveals how bureaucratic silence becomes a form of legal consent—and why public denial only accelerates the plan. Read More...

In October 2025, a Facebook page tied to Benoit First Nation and Jasen Benwah — Penwaaq L’nu’k – Kji-Wikuom — assured readers that “self-government has nothing to do with private or Crown lands.” It’s a comforting line, but legally false. Every self-government framework in Canada is rooted in land, because once the federal government recognizes a community under section 35, the discussion automatically moves into Crown-land jurisdiction.This piece explains why Newfoundland’s situation is no exception, and how the recent Cowichan Tribes v. Canada ruling in British Columbia shattered the idea that private property sits beyond Indigenous title. As the courts redefine ownership and governments scramble to catch up, the gap between “theory” and “fact” isn’t measured in years anymore — sometimes, it’s only a few hours. Read More...